Home/Blog/Property Maintenance
Property Maintenance8 min read

Frozen Pipes in a Vacant House: The Heat-or-Drain Condition and What Courts Have Required

Most homeowners and dwelling policies exclude freeze damage while a house is vacant or unoccupied, unless the owner used reasonable care to maintain heat or to shut off the water and drain the system. Courts in Arkansas, Texas, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Louisiana have read that sentence closely: shutting off the water without draining is not enough, the duty cannot be handed to a tenant, and the insurer may still have to prove freezing caused the burst. What the wording says, what the cases held, and the record that proves reasonable care.

Freeze damage is one of the costliest losses in a vacant house, and one of the most often denied. The reason is a single sentence that appears, in close variations, in most homeowners and dwelling policies: no coverage for freezing of plumbing, heating or air conditioning while the dwelling is vacant, unoccupied or being constructed, unless you have used reasonable care to maintain heat in the building, or to shut off the water supply and drain the system and appliances of water. Courts in five of the states we cover have applied it. Here is what they required.

The Wording

The 1991 Texas promulgated homeowners form, reproduced by the Texas Supreme Court in Balandran v. Safeco, 972 S.W.2d 738 (Tex. 1998), excluded loss caused by freezing while the building is unoccupied unless the insured used reasonable care to maintain heat, or to shut off the water supply and drain plumbing, heating and air conditioning systems of water. The policies in the Arkansas, Ohio and Pennsylvania cases below use the broader trigger, vacant, unoccupied or being constructed. Texas insurers have filed their own forms since 2003, so the exact sentence depends on the policy, but the two routes, heat or drain, are the common structure.

Some forms go further. The Texas FAIR Plan Association's dwelling policy, edition of October 28, 2024, removes freezing of plumbing, heating or air conditioning systems and household appliances from its covered perils altogether, and its eligibility page lists freezing among the perils it does not cover.

What the Courts Required

  • Shut off is not drained. Fulton v. Beacon National Insurance Co., 2012 Ark. App. 320 (Ark. Ct. App. May 2, 2012): a vacant rental's attic pipe froze. Because the clause joins shut off and drain with and, the owner had to show reasonable care to drain the system as well; he admitted he had not. Summary judgment for the insurer affirmed
  • The duty cannot be handed off. Dougherty v. Allstate, 185 F. Supp. 3d 585 (E.D. Pa. 2016): a house listed for sale while the owner lived in Colorado; the oil furnace failed and a pipe burst. The court adopted the position that the duty to maintain heat is the insured's and cannot be delegated, and a lease putting furnace upkeep on a former tenant did not show reasonable care. Summary judgment for Allstate
  • Winterizing has to hold. 190 E. 15th Ave., L.L.C. v. State Farm, 2026-Ohio-3242 (Ohio Ct. App. 10th Dist. Aug. 20, 2026): a Columbus rental winterized in fall 2019, with the main valve off, lines drained and antifreeze in the traps, was found with a split pipe in January 2020. The owner's theory was that someone turned the water back on; the jury verdict for State Farm was affirmed
  • Causation still has to be shown. ASI Lloyds v. Lytell, 781 F. Supp. 2d 326 (E.D. La. 2011): the insureds conceded they had neither heated nor drained, but the insurer's summary judgment was denied because whether freezing caused the burst was a fact question
  • The building, not the unit. American National v. Fredrich 2 Partners, 408 S.W.3d 610 (Tex. App.—El Paso 2013): under a commercial policy requiring the insured to do its best to maintain heat in the building, heating the occupied unit covered a freeze above the vacant one

What Reasonable Care Looks Like in the Record

Every case turned on what the owner could show about the house before the freeze. The policies do not say what proof is enough; the opinions show what was missing. A record that answers the question has two branches.

  • If relying on heat: the thermostat setting, the fuel or utility account showing service was on, and dated visit notes or photographs of the thermostat and furnace through the cold months; Dougherty is the warning about assuming someone else kept it on
  • If relying on draining: the date the main was shut off, the lines blown or drained, the water heater drained, and antifreeze in traps and toilets, each photographed, plus the shutoff left tagged and closed
  • Either way: visit logs after hard freezes, because 190 E. 15th shows that a winterization undone by someone else does not help the owner
  • Where a utility outage is the cause, the outage record; TDI's 2021 bulletin said reasonableness turns on the circumstances, including outages beyond the policyholder's control

The method is covered in winterizing a vacant property in the South and the property winterization guide. For the separate 60-day vacancy clause, which can suspend other coverage, see the 60-day vacancy clause.

Ethreon winterizes vacant houses and checks them through the cold months with its own local crews across Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, Alabama, Ohio and Pennsylvania: shutoff, drain-down and antifreeze photographed and dated, thermostats and utilities checked on each visit, and a visit after hard freezes. See winterization, vacant property checks, or check coverage.

Send Your Scope

Frequently Asked Questions

1Does insurance cover frozen pipes in a vacant house?

Usually only if the owner used reasonable care to maintain heat in the building, or to shut off the water supply and drain the system and appliances of water. The common wording, as quoted in court opinions, excludes freeze loss while the dwelling is vacant, unoccupied or being constructed unless one of those steps was taken. The Texas FAIR Plan's dwelling form does not cover freezing of plumbing at all.

2Is shutting off the water enough to keep freeze coverage?

Not under the common wording. In Fulton v. Beacon National Insurance Co., 2012 Ark. App. 320, the Arkansas Court of Appeals held that because the clause says shut off the water supply and drain the system, the owner had to show reasonable care to drain as well, and he admitted he had not. Summary judgment for the insurer was affirmed.

3Can a landlord rely on a tenant to keep the heat on in a vacant rental?

In Dougherty v. Allstate, 185 F. Supp. 3d 585 (E.D. Pa. 2016), the court adopted the insurer's position that the duty to use reasonable care to maintain heat is imposed on the insured by the policy and cannot be delegated. A lease that put furnace upkeep on a former tenant did not show reasonable care, and Allstate won summary judgment.

4Does the insurer have to prove the pipe burst from freezing?

Causation can still matter. In ASI Lloyds v. Lytell, 781 F. Supp. 2d 326 (E.D. La. 2011), the parties agreed the insureds had neither maintained heat nor shut off and drained the water, but the court denied the insurer's summary judgment because whether freezing actually caused the burst was a fact question for the jury.

5If one unit of a building is heated, is the vacant unit covered?

Under one commercial policy, yes. In American National Property & Casualty Co. v. Fredrich 2 Partners, 408 S.W.3d 610 (Tex. App.—El Paso 2013), the policy required the insured to do its best to maintain heat in the building, and heating the occupied unit satisfied it, because the condition attached to the building, not to each unit. The wording differs from most homeowners forms, so the result may not carry over.

6What did Texas say about freeze claims after the February 2021 storm?

TDI Commissioner's Bulletin B-0010-21 told insurers that a determination whether a policyholder took reasonable actions to prevent a loss must be based on the unique circumstances of the claim, and that the frequency and length of power outages prevented many policyholders from maintaining heat, which was beyond their control.

Keep Reading

More guides for property teams.

Property Maintenance

Security Deposit Deductions by State: Deadlines, Penalties, and the Proof a Landlord Needs

Every state we cover lets a landlord deduct damage from a security deposit, and every one sets a deadline for the refund or itemized list, from 30 days to 60. None of the statutes requires move-out photographs or a checklist. Texas and Pennsylvania put the burden of proving the damage on the landlord, and the penalty for a missed deadline runs as high as $100 plus three times the amount withheld. A side-by-side, and the record that carries the burden.

Property Maintenance

Rekeying Between Tenants in Texas: Property Code 92.156, the Seven-Day Rule, and the Penalty

Texas requires a residential landlord to rekey every key, card or combination lock at its own expense no later than the seventh day after each tenant turnover date. The statute defines that date as move-in, not move-out, sets a civil penalty of one month's rent plus $500, and limits when the cost can come out of a deposit. What the rule covers, what it does not, and how to show it was done.

REO & Compliance

Renovating a Vacant House: When the Being-Constructed Exception Saves Coverage and When It Does Not

Investors and estates renovating an empty house often assume the work keeps the policy alive. Many policies agree, saying a dwelling being constructed, altered or repaired is not considered vacant. Courts have read that narrowly: an Eighth Circuit panel required substantial continuing activities, and Texas, Ohio and Arkansas courts have sent vacancy to a jury on the facts. The residual-market plans set their own renovation rules. What the cases held, and the record that shows the work was real.