Deposit disputes turn on one question: can the landlord show the damage was there, and that the tenant caused it? None of the seven state statutes we read requires a move-out photograph, an inspection or a checklist. Two of them, Texas and Pennsylvania, say in terms that the landlord carries the burden of proof, and all of them punish a missed deadline. Here is what each statute requires, and the record that answers the question.
The Seven States at a Glance
| State | Deadline | Penalty for failure | Burden or wear rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Texas | 30 days after surrender (Prop. Code 92.103), once a written forwarding address is given (92.107) | Bad faith: $100 plus three times the amount wrongfully withheld, plus attorney's fees (92.109(a)); bad faith presumed after 30 days (92.109(d)) | Landlord must prove retention was reasonable (92.109(c)); no deduction for normal wear and tear (92.104(b)) |
| Oklahoma | 45 days after termination, delivery of possession and the tenant's written demand (41 O.S. 115(B)) | Tenant recovers the deposit and any prepaid rent (115(E)) | Deductions for accrued rent and damages from noncompliance with the act and the agreement |
| Alabama | 60 days after termination and delivery of possession (Code 35-9A-201(b), (c)) | Double the original deposit if the refund or accounting is not mailed in 60 days (201(f)) | Deductions for damages from noncompliance with 35-9A-301 |
| Louisiana | Refund within one month after the lease ends; itemized statement within one month or 15 days after it (R.S. 9:3251(A), as amended by Act 63 of 2026) | Willful failure: the amount withheld plus $300 or twice that amount, whichever is greater (9:3252); attorney's fees at the court's discretion (9:3253) | Retention allowed to remedy a default or unreasonable wear |
| Arkansas | 60 days after termination and delivery of possession (A.C.A. 18-16-305, as amended by Act 559 of 2009) | Not summarized: we could not read the penalty section from a primary source | Deductions for unpaid rent and damages from noncompliance with the rental agreement |
| Ohio | 30 days after termination and delivery of possession (R.C. 5321.16(B)) | Amount due plus damages equal to the amount wrongfully withheld, plus attorney's fees (5321.16(C)) | Deductions for past-due rent and damages from noncompliance with 5321.05 or the agreement |
| Pennsylvania | 30 days after termination or surrender and acceptance (L&T Act 512(a)) | No list in 30 days: forfeits the right to withhold or to sue for damage (512(b)); failure to pay: double the amount wrongfully withheld (512(c)) | Landlord bears the burden of proof of actual damages (512(c)) |
What a Deduction Has to Be For
The statutes agree that a deposit covers unpaid rent and damage the tenant is responsible for, and differ on how they say it. Texas allows deductions for damages and charges the tenant is legally liable for under the lease or for breaching it, and bars any deduction for normal wear and tear (Sections 92.104(a) and (b)). Louisiana lets the landlord keep what is reasonably necessary to remedy a default or unreasonable wear (R.S. 9:3251(A)). Ohio ties damages to the tenant's statutory duties in R.C. 5321.05, Alabama to the tenant's duties in Section 35-9A-301, and Oklahoma, Arkansas and Pennsylvania to the tenant's noncompliance with the act or the agreement and the actual damage caused. In each, the question for a disputed deduction is the same: what changed, and who caused it.
Where the Burden Sits
Texas Property Code Section 92.109(c) says that in a tenant's action, the landlord has the burden of proving that retaining any portion of the deposit was reasonable. Pennsylvania's Section 512(c) says the burden of proof of actual damages caused by the tenant is on the landlord. Neither says what evidence meets it. A landlord who itemizes a carpet replacement and cannot show the carpet's condition at move-in and move-out is asking a court to take its word, against a tenant who says the carpet was already worn.
The Itemized List
- Texas: a written description and itemized list of all deductions, with any balance; not required if the tenant owes rent on surrender and there is no dispute about the amount (Section 92.104(c)). A refund or accounting mailed and postmarked by the deadline is presumed timely (Section 92.1041)
- Oklahoma: an itemized written statement delivered by return-receipt mail, signed for by a person of statutory service age at the address, or in person if the tenant can reasonably be found (41 O.S. 115(B))
- Alabama: an itemized list of amounts withheld within the 60 days; first-class mailing to the tenant's written forwarding address within 60 days is sufficient (Code 35-9A-201(c), (e))
- Louisiana: an itemized statement accounting for the amounts kept and giving the reasons (R.S. 9:3251(A))
- Arkansas: an itemized written notice with the remainder due; first-class mailing to the last known address is compliance (A.C.A. 18-16-305)
- Ohio: an itemized written notice of deductions delivered with the amount due (R.C. 5321.16(B))
- Pennsylvania: a written list of damages the landlord claims, delivered with payment of the difference (L&T Act 512(a))
Two Rules That Catch Landlords
First, the Texas bad-faith presumption. Under Section 92.109(d), a landlord who fails to return the deposit or to provide the itemization by the 30th day after surrender is presumed to have acted in bad faith, which is what triggers $100 plus three times the amount withheld. The deadline is the turn schedule: if the unit is not inspected and photographed promptly after move-out, the itemization will be late or thin. Second, Louisiana's abandonment rule: Section 9:3251(C) says the return requirement does not apply when the tenant abandons the premises without the required notice or before the lease ends, which makes the date and condition of the abandonment worth recording.
The Record That Carries the Burden
- Move-in photographs of every room, the floors, walls, appliances, fixtures and exterior doors and windows, dated and kept with the lease
- Move-out photographs taken promptly after surrender, from the same angles, so each itemized deduction has a before and an after
- A line on each itemized deduction pointing to the photographs and to the invoice or estimate for the repair
- The date of surrender, the forwarding address and the date it was received, and proof of mailing the refund or list
- For Texas, the rekey record, kept separately; the turnover rekey is the landlord's cost and is deductible only after a lease breach with an underlined or bold clause
Photographs separate wear from damage in a way a description cannot: a worn traffic path in carpet that was already eight years old at move-in is wear; a burn, a stain or a torn section that was not in the move-in set is damage. The same photographs scope the make-ready. For the Texas rekey rule, see rekeying between tenants in Texas.
Ethreon photographs move-out condition room by room on every turn it handles, with its own local crews across the seven states it covers, and delivers the set with the make-ready scope so each deduction has its evidence. See make-ready and unit turns, cleanouts, sample report, or check coverage.
Send Your ScopeRelated Services
Ethreon delivers these services with full documentation and compliance reporting:
Frequently Asked Questions
1Does a landlord need photos to deduct from a security deposit?
No statute in the seven states we cover (Texas, Oklahoma, Alabama, Louisiana, Arkansas, Ohio and Pennsylvania) requires photographs, a move-in or move-out inspection, or a condition checklist. But Texas Property Code Section 92.109(c) and Pennsylvania's Landlord and Tenant Act Section 512(c) put the burden of proving the deductions on the landlord, and dated photographs are the most direct way to carry it.
2How long does a landlord have to return a security deposit?
Texas, Ohio and Pennsylvania: 30 days. Louisiana: one month after the lease ends, with the itemized statement allowed up to 15 days after that month since Act 63 of 2026. Oklahoma: 45 days after termination, delivery of possession and the tenant's written demand. Alabama and Arkansas: 60 days.
3What is the penalty for not returning a security deposit on time?
It varies. Texas: $100 plus three times the amount wrongfully withheld plus attorney's fees for bad faith, presumed if the refund or itemization is late. Alabama: double the original deposit if the refund or accounting is not mailed within 60 days. Louisiana: the amount withheld plus $300 or twice that amount, whichever is greater, for willful failure. Ohio: the amount due plus an equal amount in damages and attorney's fees. Pennsylvania: double the amount wrongfully withheld, and forfeiture of the right to withhold or sue for damage if no list is sent in 30 days. Oklahoma: recovery of the deposit and any prepaid rent.
4Can a landlord deduct for normal wear and tear?
Not in Texas: Section 92.104(b) says a landlord may not retain any portion of a deposit to cover normal wear and tear. Louisiana allows retention to remedy unreasonable wear. The other states tie deductions to unpaid rent and to damage from the tenant's noncompliance with the lease or the tenant's statutory duties, without using the phrase wear and tear.
5What if the tenant does not leave a forwarding address?
In Texas the landlord need not refund or itemize until the tenant gives a written forwarding address, but the tenant does not forfeit the deposit by failing to (Section 92.107). In Pennsylvania a tenant who gives no written new address relieves the landlord of liability under Section 512. In Ohio such a tenant loses the damages and attorney's fees remedy. In Alabama the landlord mails to the last known address or the property, and unclaimed deposits are forfeited after 90 days.
