An empty house being renovated sits between two kinds of insurance. A homeowners or dwelling policy expects someone living there and may cut coverage after 30 or 60 days of vacancy. Many of those policies soften the rule with one sentence, that a dwelling being constructed, altered or repaired is not considered vacant. Whether a particular renovation counts has been litigated, and the answer depends on how much work was really going on, and how well the owner can show it.
The Exception, and How Narrow It Is
In Vennemann v. Badger Mutual Insurance Co., 334 F.3d 772 (8th Cir. 2003), the owner bought a house in July 2000, never lived there, stayed overnight about twice a week, and did sporadic projects: tiling, cleaning, a new roof and an air-conditioning unit. A fire in September triggered a 30-day vandalism vacancy clause. The court agreed that remodeling must consist of substantial continuing activities to fall within the being-constructed exception, found about $5,000 of discrete work did not, and noted that even the roof, finished weeks before the fire, was not continuing. Sporadic visits and projects, it said, do not convey the appearance of residential living.
When Vacancy Goes to a Jury
- Columbia Lloyds v. Mao, No. 02-10-00063-CV (Tex. App.—Fort Worth Mar. 24, 2011): a Fort Worth rental emptied for a remodel burned in October 2006 under a Texas Dwelling Policy with a 60-day clause and no construction exception. Applying the Texas definition of vacant as entire abandonment, without contents of substantial utility, the court held conflicting evidence, including ongoing work, utilities on and twice-weekly showings, made vacancy a jury question
- Farm Bureau v. Davenport, 2017 Ark. App. 207: a furnished second home with working utilities and stocked food, visited by the owners' son, was burglarized and burned. The 30-day vandalism and 60-day all-loss provision was an exclusion despite its Conditions heading, so the insurer bore the burden, and the owner's jury verdict was affirmed
- Williamson v. Farmers, 2026-Ohio-2530: a Dayton duplex with both units empty and the owner cleaning and repairing. The policy defined vacant as the absence of most of the furniture and items needed for occupancy, and the court found a fact issue on dwelling damage, while holding stolen tools excluded
The pattern is consistent: courts look at what was in the house, whether utilities were on, how often people were there, and whether work was ongoing. Those are facts an owner either documented at the time or did not.
What Renovation Does Not Fix
- Theft of materials and tools: the Williamson policy excluded theft of construction materials and supplies until the dwelling is finished or occupied
- Slow damage from the work itself: in Wehrenberg v. Metropolitan, 228 F. Supp. 3d 512 (W.D. Pa. 2017), a year-long gutting by a tenant-contractor was not a sudden loss, whatever the vacancy wording
- Freeze damage: the freezing exclusion usually names being constructed alongside vacant and unoccupied; see frozen pipes in a vacant house
Residual-Market Renovation Rules
- Ohio FAIR Plan: a vacant house is insurable only under the Rehabilitation Program, which requires significant work on electrical, heating and plumbing, not cosmetic renovation; a start within 30 days; one year maximum; and a property vacant and secured from trespass, with inspections of progress
- Pennsylvania FAIR Plan: vacant buildings not boarded up may be insured while rehabilitation or reconstruction is actively in process, with vandalism coverage available; a building vacant more than a year qualifies only under active professional renovation starting within 30 days with contracts submitted; the vacant-dwelling limit does not apply to buildings actively under renovation
- Texas FAIR Plan: a dwelling undergoing renovation is one criterion for an interior and exterior inspection, and property in disrepair is ineligible until repaired, though the 90-day underwriting period may be used
- Alabama Insurance Underwriting Association (coastal Baldwin and Mobile counties): vacant property is ineligible, but properties being constructed may be eligible for builder's risk coverage
Builder's risk is the policy written for a structure under construction. We found no state insurance department publication explaining when it fits a renovation of an existing house, so that choice is one for the owner's agent; the plan rules above are what the residual markets say.
The Record That Shows the Work Was Real
- The contract, scope and schedule, and the permits where required
- Dated photographs of progress at each visit, room by room, so continuing activity is visible on a timeline
- A visit and work log with dates crews were on site
- Utilities on, and photographs showing the house secured at the end of each workday
- Materials and tools stored locked or off site, since theft of them is often excluded
Ethreon handles rehab scopes, securing and progress documentation for investors and estates across the seven states it covers, with its own local crews: work dated and photographed at every visit, the house locked and checked between work days, and a timeline an adjuster or underwriter can follow. See repairs and rehab, vacant property checks, lock change and securing, or check coverage.
Send Your ScopeRelated Services
Ethreon delivers these services with full documentation and compliance reporting:
Frequently Asked Questions
1Is a house under renovation considered vacant for insurance?
Many policies say a dwelling being constructed, altered or repaired is not considered vacant. Courts read the exception narrowly. In Vennemann v. Badger Mutual, 334 F.3d 772 (8th Cir. 2003), the court required substantial continuing activities and held that sporadic remodeling, about $5,000 of discrete projects with the roof finished weeks before the fire, did not qualify.
2Does cleaning and minor repair count as being repaired?
It was disputed in Williamson v. Farmers, 2026-Ohio-2530 (Ohio Ct. App. 2d Dist.), where the insurer argued that the owner's cleaning did not rise to construction, alteration or repair. The court decided the case on the policy's definition of vacant instead, the absence of most furniture and items needed for occupancy, and found a fact issue on whether the duplex was vacant.
3Who has to prove a house was vacant, the insurer or the owner?
Often the insurer. In Farm Bureau Mutual v. Davenport, 2017 Ark. App. 207, the Arkansas Court of Appeals held that a 30-day vandalism and 60-day vacancy provision was an exclusion even though it appeared under Conditions, so the insurer bore the burden, and occupancy was a jury question. In Columbia Lloyds v. Mao (Tex. App.—Fort Worth 2011), conflicting evidence on vacancy during a remodel was also a jury question.
4Are stolen tools and materials covered during a renovation?
Often not. The policy in Williamson excluded theft of construction materials and supplies used in construction, alteration or repair until the dwelling is finished or occupied, and the court held the theft of the owner's generators and tools excluded. The 1991 Texas homeowners form excluded theft of building materials and supplies not on the residence premises.
5Can a FAIR plan insure a vacant house under renovation?
Some can, on conditions. The Ohio FAIR Plan's Rehabilitation Program requires significant electrical, heating and plumbing work, a start within 30 days and a one-year maximum. The Pennsylvania FAIR Plan allows vacant buildings not boarded up while rehabilitation is actively in process. Alabama's coastal plan says properties being constructed may be eligible for builder's risk coverage.
